Thermal greases or thermal phase change materials – you choose
As many of you know, providing an adequate thermally conductive interface between a component and its heatsink is essential to achieving long life and reliability. Traditionally, thermal greases have been the material of choice in this area, but new thermal phase change materials are now said to offer a stable alternative that is easier to apply. Thermal greases have relatively low thermal resistance and offer excellent thermal performance for a vast range of applications. Their ability to provide that all-important thermal interface has been proven time after time and they have consequently become the material of choice for the thermal management of power electronics.
However, greases do have disadvantages such as application and migration issues. Now, thanks to the consistency and performance of new thermal phase change materials, Electrolube say these disadvantages are completely avoidable.
Phase change materials offer subtle differences in properties compared with greases as they store and release thermal energy (latent heat) during the process of changing from one phase (solid) to another (liquid) at the phase change temperature. Heat dissipated from electronic components is effectively stored in the phase change material as it transitions from a solid to a liquid state.
Phase change materials, once heated above their phase change temperature, become highly thixotropic liquids that perform as well as - and sometimes even better than – a traditional thermal grease. As phase change materials are said to offer greater long-term stability compared with thermal greases, they are better suited to thermally challenging applications where product life expectancy and reliability may be critical such as LED lighting, automotive electronics and remotely located wind power inverters.
Electrolube recently added two new thermally conductive phase change materials to its thermal management product portfolio: TPM350 and TPM550. According to the company, considerable interest has been shown in these new materials, since their launch at Electronica last year. Electrolube’s Chinese team has been particularly successful in developing the market for the new phase change materials and is leading the way in developing the market with local manufacturers of power electronics and LED lighting to purchase or trial the new products.
TPM350 has a thermal conductivity of 3.5W/m.K and becomes workable at approximately 50°C. At this 'activation' temperature the material changes state, minimizing contact thermal resistance and improving thermal conductivity. Once it cools, it reverts back to its original state. The RoHS compliant material is exceptionally easy to apply - similar to grease but without the mess and pump-out, and can be screen printed for high volume production applications. TPM350 is also dry to the touch, which is particularly useful for pre-apply applications.
TPM550 has a higher thermal conductivity of 5.5W/m.K and an activation temperature of 45˚C. In common with the TPM350 product, TPM550 is also screen printable and thixotropic, which prevents flow outside of defined interfaces. Both TPM350 and TPM550 are silicone-free, have an operating temperature range of -40 to +125˚C and can be easily reworked.
Electrolube says making a choice between traditional thermal greases and one of the new thermal phase change materials is essentially a case of horses for courses, although for some applications, in particular high power electronics and applications with wide ranging thermal cycling, the stability of a phase change material will be of great benefit. Phase change materials completely avoid the problems associated with pump-out and offer highly efficient thermal transfer and enhanced performance with thermal shock cycles. They also provide greater thermal protection where temperature spikes can occur due to their ability to store and release thermal energy during the phase change process